|
Barer c. Knight Brothers |
2017 QCCA 597 |
COURT OF APPEAL
CANADA
PROVINCE OF QUEBEC
REGISTRY OF MONTREAL
|
No: |
500-09-026130-161 |
|
|
|
(500-17-076332-132) |
|
|
|
|
MINUTES OF THE HEARING |
|
|
|
DATE: |
April 5th, 2017 |
CORAM: THE HONOURABLE |
PAUL VÉZINA, J.A. |
|
APPELLANT |
COUNSEL |
|
DAVID BARER
|
Mtre LEON J. GREENBERG (Sternthal, Katznelson, Montigny sencrl)
|
|
RESPONDENT |
COUNSEL |
|
KNIGHT BROTHERS LLC
|
Mtre JONATHAN L. FRANKLIN (Franklin & Franklin) Mtre LAZAR SARNA
|
On appeal from a judgment rendered on May 5th, 2016 by the Honourable Justice Marc-André Blanchard of the Superior Court, District of Montreal. |
|
DESCRIPTION: |
Recognition and enforcement of a foreign judgment. |
|
Clerk: Elisabeth Lanctôt |
Courtroom: Pierre-Basile-Mignault |
|
|
|
HEARING |
|
|
|
2:01 |
Commencement of the hearing. |
|
|
Argumentation by Mtre Leon J. Greenberg. |
|
3:09 |
Argumentation by Mtre Jonathan L. Franklin. |
|
3:20 |
Rebuttal by Mtre Greenberg. |
|
3:28 |
Suspension. |
|
3:39 |
Resumption. |
|
3:40 |
BY THE COURT : Unanimous judgment rendered orally by the Honourable Justice Robert M. Mainville - see page 3. |
|
|
Conclusion of the hearing. |
|
|
|
|
(s) Elisabeth Lanctôt |
|
Clerk |
BY THE COURT
|
|
|
JUDGMENT |
|
|
[1] Without endorsing all the reasons of the judge of first instance, we are nevertheless all of the view that there were sufficient elements to allow to conclude as he did.
[2] For these reasons, the appeal is dismissed with costs.
|
|
PAUL VÉZINA, J.A. |
|
|
ROBERT M. MAINVILLE, J.A. |
|
|
DENIS JACQUES, J.A. (AD HOC) |
AVIS :
Le lecteur doit s'assurer que les décisions consultées sont finales et sans appel; la consultation du plumitif s'avère une précaution utile.